Alfie
I just saw this movie last night and I feel compelled to get a few things off my chest about it.
Before I go online and compare my thoughts and analysis I'll post this so that it doesn't taint my opinion. This movie surprised me. I didn't think I would be thinking about it the next day. I thought it was going to be a standard "feel-good" movie. Forgettable. It was and it wasn't.
It seems to me that the movie was written by a loser. Not a loser. An anti-Alfie. A guy who rides a scooter because he's got no money and thinks he knows what guys like Alfie would say to women. Which doesn't bode well. Case in point: the scene where Alfie is in the club trying to pick up the two lesbians. If you pay attention to what he's saying, it's something along the vein of "I really don't think it's fair for women to be treated so unfairly, I mean, if you two, say, for example, wanted to kiss, I don't think that should be a problem..." This is NOT smooth, I'm sorry to say. It's something that would NOT work unless you look like this guy looks (which I was reminded constantly - he's HOT). But that dialogue didn't ring true. Neither did his infatuation with Susan Sarandon. After that model chick he goes out with he wants to settle down with Susan Sarandon because she's "like him"? COme on, that makes no sense at all.
Also, this Alfie character is a player right? Smooth, gets the girl, fast talker? He knows about wine and high fashion, right? And he doesn't know what Absynthe is? Please. Some of these details make him out to be this dumb jock who doesn't play sports but only has his looks and a limited amount of information about clothing and the awareness of how attractive he is to women. And if that was what the writer was going for than this movie is a waste of time.
Then the ending. I'm glad it didn't end the way stories end - it wasn't nicely wrapped in a bow. It doesn't really end or tell you what "will happen in the end." Which I like. I like that. But the phrase that kept popping into my head the whole time was "mental masturbation" as the movie finished. What was the point of taking us through 105 minutes of film? For what? The guy is right back where he started. It's kind of like Memento without all the cool memory shit. What's the deal? So he's screwed, he'll never find someone, why didn't I care? Umm, because he was a jerk? If I'm not sympathetic to this guy then this kind of ending really doesn't do much for me.
OK, also, Marissa Tomei. So he just screws her, but he says how her kid is "irresistible.?
And everyone goes, ?awww.? Turns out this guy might have a redeeming quality after all. But not really. He hugs the kid once and weeks later asks if he?s ok and for her to say ?hi? to him. He screwed his best friend?s girlfriend and got her pregnant! This guy isn?t a very good guy.
Yet it seems that his so-called ?smooth? personal should make us care about him. As for women, I guess the good looks get them to care about him along with his ?sensitive? side.
It just doesn?t fit together.
Then there?s the model chick. We don?t care about her either. She?s hot, that?s it. But suddenly we?re supposed to feel sorry for her because the magic word (medication) is uttered? I don?t think so. All we know of her is that she?s hot, she?s schizophrenic, and the two montages we get of her is of living like a supermodel, then trashing his place and being overall crazy. Why would I care about this character? I don?t. Bad job, writer.
Ok why do I have so much to say about this movie? No idea. It got me irked pretty good though. And it?s not that I disliked it all that much, it?s not that.
Who knows.
Oh and the wordplay, I liked that part. Especially at the beginning with his vocabulary calendar, if you pay close attention to the word for the next day after the one he takes and talks about, it's "doom".
Posted by portocac
at 11:50 AM CST
Updated: Tuesday, 22 March 2005 12:15 PM CST